Emotional Responses to Antique Art

adult learning, apples, art, beauty, Cezanne, Creativity, Icons, incarnation, inspiration, Love, Ministry, Painting

Sometimes we struggle so hard to paint the image before us—the form, shadows, the colors, and lines—we forget to also paint our emotional response to the subject matter also. In the matter of faith, John Wesley once said, “There have been many in every age and nation, who were almost persuaded to be Christians, but are not altogether a Christian.” Some have the outward appearance of religion, but not the inner heart of a transformed person, that is, they do all that is expected of a religious person: honesty, generosity, service, worship attendance, but they lack “sincerity.” Wesley, in his sermon, The Almost Christian, writes:

“By Sincerity, I mean, a real, inward principle of religion, from whence these outward actions flow. And, indeed, if we have not this, we have not heathen honesty; no, not so much of it as will answer the demand of a heathen epicurean poet. Even this poor wretch, in his sober intervals, is able to testify: Good men avoid sin from the love of virtue: Wicked men avoid sin from a fear of punishment.”

In art class, a student can master the skills of image making with practice, but taking the time to discover their own inner voice is more challenging. I would equate it to Wesley’s own experience of transforming grace, which occurred at the Aldersgate meeting place:

“In the evening I went very unwillingly to a society in Aldersgate Street, where one was reading Luther’s preface to the Epistle to the Romans. About a quarter before nine, while the leader was describing the change which God works in the heart through faith in Christ, I felt my heart strangely warmed. I felt I did trust in Christ alone for salvation; and an assurance was given me that He had taken away my sins, even mine, and saved me from the law of sin and death.”

Before this experience, this preacher’s son never doubted his faith, but it was never personal. He had the faith of assent, but not the faith of assurance. We English speaking people often confuse faith and belief. In Greek the word for faith or belief is πίστις, which comes from the verb πείθω, meaning “to persuade, to convince, to trust, or to have confidence.” Faith (πίστις/pistis) involves belief, but it goes beyond human believing. The true faith of assurance involves God working within personal revelation. Faith is always God’s work. Our believing has eternal meaning when it becomes “faith-believing” by the transforming grace of God.

We artists understand this transformation of the heart in creative terms. We need to move from our head to our hearts to get our whole selves involved in our work. If we use only a part of our being, we are less than the wonderful self which God created. Too often we slip into a Greek platonic heresy, especially when we denigrate the body as nothing. God sent his Son Jesus in human flesh with a mind, a heart, and a soul to redeem the whole of fallen creation to God’s original glory. 

 

Marc Chagall: The Tale of the Ebony Horse, lithograph, 1948, Cleveland Museum of Art

As artists, we try to unite the colors, shapes, lines, and images on our canvases to bring the beauty of creation and harmony into this world of chaos and destruction. While we are not gods, we are creators. We yearn for beauty, joy, and love. As Marc Chagall once said,

“If I create from the heart, nearly everything works; if from the head, almost nothing.”        

Amedeo Modigliani: Head, c. 1913, limestone, 20 5/8 × 9 3/4 × 14 3/4 in., Kimbell Art Museum, Ft. Worth, Texas. 

I recently visited the Kimbell Art Museum in Fort Worth, Texas. Having brought back several postcards of artworks from various ancient eras, I showed the group other images of modern artists who were inspired by these pieces. The simplicity of forms of these pieces from early Cycladic art influenced both Modigliani and Brancusi.

Constantin Brâncuși: Sleeping Muse, 1910, Painted bronze, 6 3/10 × 9 4/5 × 7 1/10 in 

I offered the cards to the group and let each one choose the image which spoke to them. Then I asked them not to copy the photograph, but to paint their emotional response to it. 

 

Paul Cézanne: Still Life with Apples and Pears, ca. 1891–92, Oil on canvas, 17 5/8 x 23 1/8 in. (44.8 x 58.7 cm), Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, NY.

Paul Cezanne, noted for his analytical approach to his paintings, nevertheless claimed, 

“A work of art which did not begin in emotion is not art.”

Mike: After Modigliani

Mike always enjoys his time in art class. His heart and hand are connected. Even if he has not yet the skills which come from practice and seeing, he has the heart of a creative. His paintings always exude joy. Back in the days of my art school—the 70’s—we would have said, “Let your freak flag fly!” Epictetus, an early 2nd CE stoic philosopher, was more profound:

“If you would improve, be content to be thought foolish and stupid.”

Gail chose the card with a mosaic of a vase and a vine. The original mosaic represents a chalice, the cup that holds the consecrated wine and water of the Eucharist. This image reminds us of the Last Supper and Christ’s sacrifice on the Cross. The ivy is an allusion to immortality.

Mosaic Chalice with Two Strands of Ivy mosaic (circa 400 AD), Kimbell Museum of Art, Fort Worth, Texas.

Gail spent her career in the National Park Service, so anything with nature calls her name. Artists always do best with a subject that speaks to them. They will walk through the woods, full of many trees, until they find the one tree with the light and the surroundings that cause them to stop in their tracks. I’ve walked through an entire forest, only to turn around at the end of my hike and see the most magnificent tree in the best light ever. It was waiting for me. I only had to hear its silent voice. If I had been in a hurry to get to my car and do the next thing on my busy life list, I would have never seen this beautiful tree. This is why some artists have their muse, or favorite still life objects, or paint certain landscapes repeatedly. 

Caspar David Friedrich, The Sea of Ice, 1823–24. © Hamburger Kunsthalle / bpk Photo by Elke Walford. Courtesy of Hamburger Kunsthalle

Caspar David Friedrich, the German romantic landscape artist, reminds us:

“The task of a work of art is to recognize the spirit of nature and, with one’s whole heart and intention, to saturate oneself with it and absorb it and give it back again in the form of a picture.”

Gail often envisions her paintings in her mind before she commits her brush to the canvas. If she isn’t seeing a complete image, she has already sketched out in her mind the rough proportions and planned out the colors she wants to begin with. Only then does she begin to work in dialogue with the emerging image. As an artist begins to put colors and shapes on a surface, each stroke changes the dynamics of the blank area. It takes time to learn to be comfortable with those shifting marks.

I always suggest making a preliminary sketch with a line of light-yellow paint wash. Painting over this sketch is easy and it lets you know if you have your shapes correctly sized for the canvas. Gail has been doing this long enough that it is second nature for her. 

Gail’s Reinterpretation of the Mosaic

While the rough mosaic stones of the original force the lyric vines into a stylized rhythm, Gail painted the vase and vines more naturally using the liquid medium of paint. Gail often thins her paint into washes which she layers on top of one another to get the colors and depth of shadows in her works. In this painting, she uses free brushstrokes. If she had more time, she might have added some yellow highlights to the leaves, but we were working with a limited color palette. I didn’t look to see if yellow was a chosen color. We were using up our oldest tubes of colors as part of the challenge in the limited palette. 

Caspar David Friedrich, Wanderer above the Sea of Fog, ca. 1817. © SHK / Hamburger Kunsthalle / bpk. Photo by Elke Walford. Courtesy of Hamburger Kunsthalle.

 Friedrich repeatedly used a technique called Rückenfiguren—figures with their backs turned to the viewer so that their expression is concealed. An artist uses this method as a means to encourage or invite the viewer to reflect on what it means to see.

Unknown Cycladic Artist: Marble head of a figure, 2100 BCE, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, NYC, Leonard N. Stern Collection, Loan from the Hellenic
Republic, Ministry of Culture.

My oldest tubes are earth colors and deep chemical blues. I most often paint in a bright color scheme. In my last months of college, I made many black and gray paintings. My dear parents were worried I was depressed. When they found out I was merely using up my least favorite pigments so they wouldn’t go to waste, they were relieved. They grew up in the Great Depression era and believed in wasting nothing. My daddy kept all his bent boat motor propellers nailed to his workshop wall, waiting for the day when it would be cheaper to hammer them true rather than buy a new one. He always bought a new one because a machine could make them better than a human hitting an old-fashioned anvil. 

Cornelia: Meditation on an Antique Sculpture

When a face has no eyes or mouth, and it has no ears or distinctive hair, who is it? Is it our inner self, or the god we imagine in our own image? Could it be our ancestor/s? The unknown and uncertainty of this identity, or this object’s lack of identity, I find both unsettling and attractive. It has both a light and a dark side: a side for good which it would show to all, and a side which it would hide from everyone, if possible.

In human terms, we suppress our negative traits and project them onto the “other.” We only see the bright and positive side in ourselves and those like us. If we are ever to become whole persons, we must face the darkness within us, as well as the darkness in this world about us. A split person is neither whole nor holy. 

My grandfather often told me not to point out other’s shortcomings because I had three fingers pointing back at myself. I understood if I could recognize something missing in another, I was lacking in that also. We all have room to grow in love, until our hearts are so full of love for God and neighbor that nothing else exists. When I search this empty face, I ask myself if my heart is yet overflowing with love. If it is not, I can count on the grace and mercy of God’s love in Jesus Christ to bring me further along, if only I cooperate. After all, love is a journey, just as art and the creative life is a journey to perfection. Perfection in love may look different, just as famous artists find different solutions to the challenge of beauty. 

 

DeLee: Icon of the Christ who Bears Your Burdens, 2026, acrylic on canvas, 16”x 20”

Remember, creating is a natural process for everyone. The core idea in art therapy is “Everyone is creative and can be expressive in the visual arts when working in a supportive setting.” No one will be asking us to repaint the Sistine Chapel anytime soon, but we can all enjoy giving our own expression to the blank spaces before us. Yet, perfection in love will always be the great standard which guides us all. We don’t need Ten Commandments, when two done well suffice:

“Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength.’ The second is this: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ There is no commandment greater than these.” (Mark 12:30-31)

I hope you spend your new year more focused on loving God, whose steadfast love abides forever, and loving the neighbor, whom God has placed in your path, as a recipient of God’s love shed abroad from your heart into your neighbor’s life. Our class meets on Fridays from 10 to noon. Art Fridays are a one room schoolhouse. I’ve taught all ages from preschool to adults. Bring your own supplies and you can start from where you are. You can’t be behind unless you never start. I can promise you won’t make museum quality paintings this year! However, you will be better at the end of the year than you are now. You will know more. Plus, the art life is a better, more beautiful life. 

Joyce and peace, 

Cornelia 

 

Wesley’s Sermon Reprints: The Almost Christian | Christian History Magazine

https://christianhistoryinstitute.org/magazine/article/wesleys-sermon-reprints-almost-christian

Discipleship Ministries | Aldersgate

https://www.umcdiscipleship.org/blog/aldersgate

Strong’s Greek: 3982. πείθω (peithó) — To persuade, to convince, to trust, to have confidence

http://biblehub.com/greek/3982.htm

Epictetus | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy

At any skill level, making art reduces stress hormones | ScienceDaily

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/06/160615134946.htm?ref=hyperallergic.com

 

 

Not Sad to See the Old Year Go

art, Attitudes, Creativity, Faith, Habits, Healing, Health, Icons, inspiration, Light of the World, New Year’s Day, Painting, purpose, rabbits, renewal, Spirituality, vision

Prudence: Allegory of Obedience (ca. 1320)
“Fresco” [Lower Church, San Francesco, Assisi, Italy]
Giotto di Bondone (Italian; ca. 1267 – 1337). Detail.
With her dual face, Prudence sees both past and future.

Welcome to the New Year of 2026! This year is looking much like the latter part of the old year. The good news is the first part of 2025 was a struggle, but every month afterwards was an improvement. I’ve found staying hopeful always helps recovery from any setback easier. If I keep to a regular routine, stay focused on healthy practices, and manage my stress, I can keep a positive attitude.

I have learned I need to eat at regular times, or I’m good for nothing. My first new year’s achievement is outwitting the AI Assassin in the new Office365 program update. As I age, managing new activities every year gets more difficult. I finally asked the AI for a blank document. It made me one. And now I’m writing with one finger happily. Not trying to get past its gatekeeping is a thrill. I have ended my old year on a high note!

Heinrich Kley (German, 1863-1945), Boxende Hasen; ink on paper; from the collection of The Walt Disney Family FoundationHeinrich Kley/Walt Disney Family Foundation

Our condo group was going to have a little get together and watch the old world welcome the New Year, but the flu bug decided to lay everyone low. For some reason, I’ve escaped this go round. I may be waiting for the sucker punch in the next round. I watched the first half of the football game and went upstairs to see the bitter end. Not having a dog in this hunt means I don’t remember who played, but on New Year’s Day, I got the benefit of three college bowl games! One of these was a defensive battle, the Heisman Trophy winner proved that it takes an effective team to make a quarterback great, and the SEC game is ongoing as I write.

1924 English Soap Advertisement

Folks say what you do on January 1st, you’ll do all year long. If that’s the case, I’ll be cooking, creating, and watching sports on tv. At least I took a shower and washed my hair; I know my neighbors will be glad I’ve chosen cleanliness for the new year. I don’t ascribe to the idea I might be “washing the good luck out of my life.” Instead, I believe others would count themselves lucky to be near my clean smelling self.

Some of these superstitions are geared to make us “turn over a new leaf” as we begin new habits with the new year. Fitness centers are jam packed in the first three weeks of January, but by the end of the month, the regulars will notice a real drop in attendance. By Valentine’s Day, most of the resolution driven members will have stopped attending. The regular members will have the gym back to themselves. Fact check: This superstition doesn’t actually hold true.

Lindt Gourmet Truffles are here for your Valentine

Many reasons exist for this quitting: change is difficult, some people set unrealistic goals which lead to early burnout, routines aren’t easy to establish, and new exercisers sometimes compare themselves to experienced people (and get discouraged or overwhelmed). Plus, it’s winter, and much of the country experiences bad weather and darkness before and after work. Having said this, one almost wonders how anyone keeps a New Year’s resolution! Especially when candy and cookies keep coming around!

Other new year resolutions are work oriented, for they seek to make us more productive or manage our time better. These are great if you think your purpose is to be an economic engine or to be a cog in the global economy. A Wall Street Journal survey in 2023 found the only value Americans came to care more about was making money.

DeLee: Christ for the Heavy Burdened, 2026, acrylic on canvas, 16” x 20”

I would suggest your first goal is to be more human. If time management skills help you to order your life so your faith, your integrity, your family, your health, your livelihood, and your concern for the future of our world and its people fall into proper alignment, then put those skills to the greater purpose.

Most likely, no one offering these skills will suggest how to order your priorities in any way other than to be more productive at work. They may suggest you’ll have more free time for your family, but work will notice your “efficiency” and promote you to more time consuming, yet higher paying responsibilities. In this new year of 2026, do you hear a call to tune your heart and soul to the spiritual presence of God in your life? Is there more to life than the daily grind?

When the days are cold and dark, I open my Bible to the gospel of John. John speaks of Jesus as the “light of the world,” indeed he “was life, and the life was the light of all people. The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not overcome it.”  (John 1:4-5)

There are many reasons today to be negative or to tune out the world beyond our daily lives and our families. The system seems too big or too broken to understand, repair, or change. The world is very large and we are only one small voice in its vast wilderness. We can find ourselves easily lost in the cacophony of voices telling us, “I have the solution. Follow me.”

Vintage New Year’s Card, circa 1905

How do we test the truth of these voices who promise the moon but never deliver even the cheese? First, remember these false leaders will tell you what you what you want to hear. They will speak to your fears, your angers, your hatreds, and your base desires. A true leader, however, will tell you the truth and not make promises they cannot keep. Only the spiritually strong will be able to sort the false from the true, for their hearts and minds love all their neighbors. Their only anger is against the system which often treats some privileged individuals better than others and others of lower status very badly.

Of course, I’m old and I grew up in an age in which I believed my voice counted. In high school, we held our student elections using our local government’s voting machines. Our principal trained us to expect to vote in city elections once we became eligible. In college I marched with other students for civil rights and in peace demonstrations. I was not a believer in Christ or God, but I believed in Life. I made a circuitous journey back to faith in Christ by the grace of God believing in me, even though I had quit believing in God.

To wrap this up, I say no one is ever so lost that God cannot find them. If you want one resolution to keep for this new year, read one verse in the gospel of John a day. If so moved, write it down, and jot some thoughts that come to mind. If none come at first, don’t worry. As you read more, wait more, and open your mind and heart more, thoughts will come. You can’t force this. It takes a bit to let go of all the “jumping monkeys” in our minds that call us to be busy with our “gotta get it done now” lists. Trust the process. Grow with it. There’s a learning curve.

Not showing the ugly scar! This is three months post operative. It’s barely noticeable anymore.

On a personal note, in March I had cervical neck fusion surgery. These last couple of years were painful due to the neck injury from picking up groceries. Now I’m recovering well and getting my spark back. However, I’m coming to grips with the realization I’m having to retire my Wonder Woman crown and belt. The lasso of truth, however, you’ll have to pull from my cold, dead hands. I will always tell you the truth, you can count on that. You might not like it, but as Jesus said to the ones who had believed in him, “If you continue in my word, you are truly my disciples; and you will know the truth, and the truth will make you free.” (John 8:31-32) However, don’t believe in me, but in the one who sent me! I’m just the messenger.

Blackeyed peas for good luck in 2026

For my New Year’s supper, I enjoyed a hearty bowl of blackeyed peas, brown rice, and quinoa, all simmered together with baby spinach cooked in rich leftover pot roast liquid. To finish it off, I sprinkled a bit of shredded cheddar cheese on top.

Here’s wishing everyone a prosperous, healthy, and peaceful New Year in 2026! Eat more plants, more veggies, and more home cooked meals. Spend time creating, sharing, and learning.

Joy and peace,

Cornelia

David Brooks: We’re Living Through the Great Detachment